Activist fund Tcha Partners calls for Namyang Dairy to buy back shares

It is demanding Namyang repurchase a 23.5% stake from retail investors as they don't benefit from the control premium via an M&A

Namyang Dairy Products headquarters in Seoul
Namyang Dairy Products headquarters in Seoul
Ji-Eun Ha 3
2023-02-27 17:51:22 hazzys@hankyung.com
Shareholder activism

Seoul-based activist fund Tcha Partners Asset Management Co. on Monday demanded that South Korea’s Namyang Dairy Products Co. buy back half of the shares owned by its retail investors, which equals 23.5% ownership of the company, at 820,000 won ($620.3) apiece via a tender bid. 

That price is 35% higher than the share's closing price on Feb. 24. The repurchase would reach 191.6 billion won in aggregate, comprised of 123.3 billion won in common stocks and 68.3 billion won in preferred shares.

Tcha Partners, which holds a 3% stake or 20,447 shares in the dairy products maker, has determined to begin shareholder activism on Monday as Namyang hasn’t responded to the asset manager’s letter sent on Feb. 15.

The asset manager's letter contained four proposals. The first one is that Namyang would repurchase half of the common and preferred stocks owned by retail investors to share the control premium with minority shareholders. 

Namyang Chairman Hong Won-sik and his two family members agreed to sell a combined 53.08% stake in the dairy products maker to Korean private equity firm Hahn & Co. for 310.7 billion won in 2021, slightly less than twice its market value at the time. But Namyang’s retail investors were excluded from the control premium distribution.   

Namyang stock, which surged to 813,000 won in July 2021 after Hahn & Co. announced the acquisition plan, has plunged as Chairman Hong annnounced a termination of the Hahn & Co. deal in September of the same year. Hong argued the contract was unfair and one-sided in favor of the buyer, adding that he had not even received a down payment. 

In addition to the buyback, Tcha Partners proposed that Namyang appoint Sim Hye-seop, a lawyer specializing in corporate governance, as an auditor; conduct a five-for-one stock split through changes in the articles of association; and distribute a 20,050 won dividend per preferred stock.
Namyang Chairman Hong Won-sik
Namyang Chairman Hong Won-sik


FIGHT FOR RETAIL SHAREHOLDERS' RIGHTS

Namyang stakeholders are set to vote on resolutions at the general shareholders' meeting in March. The retail investors’ votes will be decisive in nominating the auditor as Hong and his two family members, who together have a controlling stake, can execute up to 3% of shareholder voting rights under Korea’s Commercial Act.

Tcha Partners also needs Chairman Hong and his family’s agreement to pass the other resolutions.

Hahn & Co. won the first legal battle against Hong last September and the second one earlier this month. The Seoul Central District Court has ordered Hong to carry out the transaction as previously agreed. 

Namyang, previously a longtime leader in Korea’s dairy industry, has faced a series of corporate-level crises since 2013 when it was revealed that the company’s salespeople were forcing distributors to buy more of their products.

In 2021, the company faced blowback for its claim that its yogurt drink Bulgaris can protect against COVID-19. Following public backlash Hong pledged he would resign as chairman; but he has maintained the position.

“The dairy products maker’s earnings have deteriorated while the legal batles have been prolonged. We will focus on enhancing retail shareholders’ rights, which have been underestimated,” Tcha Partners said.

“Namyang’s shareholders were excluded in the recent M&A event —  at a time when the Korean government is contemplating introducing a mandatory offer rule that many developed capital markets are already practicing,” said Tcha Partners Director Kim Hyung-kyoon.

“During this transition period, we hope to secure an opportunity for Namyang's minority shareholders to realize an M&A equivalent exit opportunity,” Kim added.

Founded in 2019, Tcha Partners is an alternative investment firm with expertise in infrastructure. Its founding members are from Platform Partners Asset Management, a local activist fund that led Macquarie Korea Infrastructure Fund’s management fee cut in 2018.

Namyang shares dropped 5.57% to close at 576,000 won on the Kospi on Monday.

*Updated with comments from Kim Hyung-kyoon

Write to Ji-Eun Ha at hazzys@hankyung.com

Jihyun Kim edited this article.

Court clears way for Hahn & Co.'s Namyang Dairy deal

Court clears way for Hahn & Co.'s Namyang Dairy deal

Namyang shares have tumbled by almost half off their four-year high of 813,000 won hit in July of last year, Seoul-based private equity firm Hahn & Co. has won a legal battle against South Korea’s Namyang Dairy Products Co.’s owner family, which last year abruptly terminated a 3

Namyang top shareholder barred from casting vote at general meeting

Namyang top shareholder barred from casting vote at general meeting

Namyang Dairy Chairman Hong Won-sik announced his resignation on May 4, but remains in office Namyang Dairy Products Co.'s top shareholder and Chairman Hong Won-sik will be barred from exercising his shareholder rights at the company's general meeting on Oct. 29, according to a South Korean cou

Namyang Dairy-Hahn & Co. saga enters new chapter: Legal fight

Namyang Dairy-Hahn & Co. saga enters new chapter: Legal fight

Namyang Dairy Products Co.'s top shareholder and Chairman Hong Won-sik on Wednesday notified Hahn & Co. of the termination of the 310.7 billion won ($270 million) agreement to sell a majority of his company to the Seoul-based private equity firm. Hong's abrupt announcement, made throu

Namyang ex-chair's no-show for $300 mn deal: What's next

Namyang ex-chair's no-show for $300 mn deal: What's next

Namyang Dairy's popular yogurt drink Bulgaris on the shelves of a supermarket Hong Won-sik, ex-chairman of South Korea’s Namyang Dairy Products Co., appeared to have changed his mind shortly after signing a 310.7 billion won ($263 million) agreement with Hahn & Co. to sell a majority

Hahn & Co. sues Namyang owner over completion of $267 mn deal

Hahn & Co. sues Namyang owner over completion of $267 mn deal

South Korea’s private equity firm Hahn & Co. filed a lawsuit against the owner of Namyang Dairy Products and his family to complete a $267 million deal to buy the dairy and beverage maker.Hahn & Co. signed a deal to purchase a majority stake in the scandal-hit company at 310.7 bi

(* comment hide *}